Calif. board declines to DQ Justify for 2018 drug positive
After further review, the stewards have ruled there will be no change.
That familiar litany of racing announcers everywhere when a claim of foul is found without warrant can now be applied to the state of California as a whole.
The California Horse Racing Board (CHRB) on Wednesday dismissed positive tests for a prohibited drug involving two horses trained by Bob Baffert in 2018, including Triple Crown winner Justify.
The controversy is one I wrote about several times last year: It began with a New York Times report in September that Hall of Fame trainer’s colt had failed a drug test after winning the 2018 Santa Anita Derby but that the complaint had been swept under the rug by racing authorities.
That was significant because Justify went on to capture the Kentucky Derby a month later, en route to a Triple Crown sweep and a quick and profitable ($125,000 per assignation) retirement. That the article pointed a finger of suspicion at Baffert, whose charms are lost on many of his racing rivals, only added to its appeal.
The case, as it turned out, was almost certainly the result of Justify and other horses stabled at Santa Anita, including stablemate Hopportunity, eating feed contaminated with scopolamine, a natural substance contained in the wild-growing jimson weed plant.
The board’s quiet dismissal of the initial complaint in executive session made the matter far worse by making it appear the board was covering up something sinister and apparently led to a few hasty departures from the body.
That could have been the end of it, but fast forward to January, when a fellow named Mick Ruis took the story in a new direction by suing the CHRB for failing to disqualify Justify. Regulations in place at the time of the incident, the suit argued, required a disqualification and the elevation of the runner-up.
If you haven’t guessed by now, Ruis is the trainer and owner of said runner-up, Bolt d’Oro, who is himself retired and enjoying a licentious life at $15,000 per roll in the hay. He had 400,000 good reasons to want Justify DQ’d, as that’s the difference between first-place and second-place prize money in the $1 million race.
The racing board later reached a private settlement of the lawsuit absolving it of failing to hold a purse disqualification hearing as required by state rules. The deal included a provision that the CHRB would file a complaint against the owners of Justify and conduct a purse disqualification hearing.
That was the proceeding that led to Wednesday’s dismissal vote by the CHRB, which means that the owners of Justify and Hopportunity, who won the Tokyo City Cup Race in his next start, will keep their trophies and purse money.
The board did not second guess the previous board’s decision.
“Even if this panel were to disagree with the CHRB’s decision to dismiss these matters or the way the CHRB handled the situation, it cannot be argued that the CHRB lacked the authority to do so,” the decision said. “The law specifically allows such actions to take place and the CHRB followed the law.”
No other details of the settlement have been made public, but Ruis said at the time it was announced that the lawsuit was intended to ensure owners and trainers in California have an even playing field.
“This legal action was never just about the purse money,” he said in a statement in July. “I wanted to stand up for what’s right and to make sure that every horseman, from the little guy to Bob Baffert, is treated fairly and equally.”
Baffert, who sued the racing board in October along with the owners and jockeys of both Justify and Hopportunity, had no immediate comment on the board’s decision.
Baffert also is contesting two drug positives involving his horses in Arkansas. In that instance, racing authorities said Arkansas Derby winner Charlatan and Gamine both tested positive for lidocaine, a local anesthetic that has a variety of uses in equine medicine.
Mike Brunker’s horse racing column appears Fridays. He can be reached at mbrunker@reviewjournal.com or 702-383-4656. Follow @mike_brunker on Twitter.
Ellis Starr's analysis of the Ft. Lauderdale Stakes
A Grade 2, $200,000 race run at 1 1/8th miles on the turf for 3-year-olds and up on Saturday.
Delaware (GB) may have turned a corner in his most recent race, his fourth since importing from Europe. After an eighth place finish at Belmont in June in a stakes race in his North American debut, Delaware (GB) finished second in a high level allowance race then shipped to Woodbine to run in the King Edward Stakes, where he was sent to post as the favorite but only managed to finish fifth. Given three months off, Delaware returned in the Artie Schiller Stakes in New York and proceeded to run his best race in the states to date, rallying late to miss winning by a neck and a head. The 107 Equibase Speed Figure is much higher than the 92 figure 2019 Ft. Lauderdale winner Instilled Regard earned and the effort is likely to be improved upon in the colt's second start back after three months away from the races. North American leading jockey Irad Ortiz, Jr. rides Delaware (GB) right back after his big effort last month. With a contested early pace battle forecast between Halladay, Factor This and Somelikeithotbrown, it is very possible Delaware (GB) will be up in time to win.
Spooky Channel will likely be much further back in the early stages than Delaware (GB), but he has the kick to post the upset, just as he did last January when winning the William L. McKnight Handicap. That effort earned a career-best 117 figure, which he duplicated in May winning in a stakes quality allowance race. Jockey Julien Leparoux was aboard for both wins and rides again in the Ft. Lauderdale, which portends well for Spooky Channel potentially to post the upset with a last to first rally.
Doswell has never finished worse than second in six career turf races, at distances ranging from 7 furlongs to 1 1/4 miles. When returning from an 11-month layoff in August and changing trainers to Barclay Tagg, Doswell ran the best race of his career with a 97 figure. Nearly two months later Doswell ran even better, improving to a 104 figure. Since shipping to Florida from New York, Doswell put in a sensational 5-furlong workout on the turf in 58.6 which was the best of 17 on the day at the distance, suggesting even better may be forthcoming in the Ft. Lauderdale.
The rest of the field, with their best Equibase Speed Figures: Breaking the Rules (110), Channel Cat (108), Factor This (118), Halladay (115), Largent (109), Somelikeithotbrown (117) and Tide of the Sea (102).
