Suspect requests separate trial in casino shooting

RENO — Lawyers for a Hells Angels member charged in connection with a fatal shootout at a Nevada casino say he should be tried separately from two members of the rival Vagos gang partly because the Vagos are a criminal gang and the Hells Angels a legitimate motorcycle club.

Cesar Villagrana, accused of shooting two Vagos members during the Sept. 23 gunbattle, won’t get a fair trial if the same jury decides his fate with the two other Vagos members accused in the killing of Jeffrey “Jethro” Pettigrew, who was president of the Hells Angels chapter in San Jose, Calif., his lawyers said in court filings last week.

Attorney David Chesnoff of Las Vegas said a confidential witness who identified himself as a 27-year, high-ranking member of the Vagos testified before a Washoe County grand jury in November that the Vagos are a gang. That witness, who has left the Vagos and now is in a protection program, said the Vagos were involved in criminal activities, including murder, rape, robbery and drug trafficking, Chesnoff said.

“If this information is presented at trial,” Chesnoff wrote in a motion to sever the trial, “it would be clearly prejudicial to Mr. Villagrana because the jury may be led to believe that all motorcycle clubs operate the way the Vagos club does.”

But Deputy District Attorney Karl Hall said the Hells Angels do operate that way. “Each gang has relatively equal gang history,” he wrote in an opposition motion. “If anything, the Hells Angels criminality is more prolific.”

Chesnoff said Villagrana, 36, of Gilroy, Calif., “responded to an onslaught of violence in self-defense” at John Ascuaga’s hotel-casino in Sparks and was minimally involved compared with the two he is to stand trial with on Oct. 29 before Washoe District Judge Connie Steinheimer.

Ernesto Gonzalez, 53, the president of the Vagos chapter in Nicaragua who lives in San Francisco, is accused of fatally shooting Pettigrew in the back. He is the only one of three defendants formally charged with murder.

Villagrana and Gary Rudnick, the vice president of the Vagos Los Angeles chapter, who is accused of instigating the fracas with his taunting of Pettigrew, both are charged with conspiracy to engage in an affray and challenge to fight resulting in death.